Back to the insights archive
Legal updates

Breakthrough judgment: Franc credit invalidated

Court 2 Once first in Poland he considered the credit agreement concluded in francs invalid.

Court 2 Once first in Poland he considered the credit agreement concluded in francs invalid.

The main argument of the judgment was that the bank knew about the exchange rate risk at the time of granting the loan and did not inform the client.

A lot of people who took a franc credit a few years ago...

Court 2 Once first in Poland he considered the credit agreement concluded in francs invalid. The main argument of the judgment was that the bank knew about the exchange rate risk at the time of granting the loan and did not inform the client.

Many people who have taken a franc credit a few years ago now have a much larger amount to pay than would have been due to standard debt indexation.

This situation is due to an adverse frank rate for borrowers, which the banks have been warned about by the NBP or the KNF and which they have not informed their customers or informed in an ambiguous manner. one with customers in 2008 she took a loan of 485,925.37 PLN, a 10 years of regular repayment had to be given approx. 500,000 PLN.

The client filed a lawsuit, claiming a partial cancellation of the contract. The Court of First Instance considered that the burden on customers of exchange rate risks did not fall within the definition of a credit agreement contained in banking law and considered the entire contract invalid.

The bank is still entitled to a cassation complaint, which it is likely to benefit from. If the SN has a judgment similar to the court 2 instances, the customer will return the loan without interest, fees or increases resulting from indexation.

reference no. VI ACa 427/18

Source: Republic of

Continue exploring our insights.

View the full archive
Legal updates

Obligations of traders to provide non-cash payments

As part of the amendment package under the noisy name Polish Deal, which most of the solutions entered into force at the beginning of January 2022, to stimulate a new impetus for the gradually growing trend in the market for non-cash payments, and at the same time to counter and combat the gray...

Legal updates

Deduction – what is involved and when possible

Deduction is a legal institution regulated in Article 498-505 KC.

Legal updates

Business secrecy in the context of changes to the Public Finance Act - comment

From 1 July 2022 information on all contracts exceeding the value 500 PLN, which from the beginning of this year have been concluded by public authorities (including JST), will be public and will be entered in the register kept by the Minister of Finance.